During apple harvest think about ordering a pound of homemade fudge with an apple gift pack. Papa's Lake Fudge is Homemade with all natural ingredients like real butter and cream, so you can count on creamy, delicious fudge every time. Whether you enjoy fresh fudge with nuts or without, dark chocolate fudge or vanilla fudge, fudge filled with chewy carmel or plain, we have the fudge flavor for you. We make over 4,000 pounds of fresh fudge every year, and with 17 unique flavors, the choice isn't easy, but it will be delicious! It's easy to order our homemade, fresh fudge online.
All fudge is sold by the pound. Enjoy!
*Please note we do not ship fudge if the temperature is above 70 degrees. Unless you want fudge soup...
Chocolate Mint Swirl is one of the most popular flavors--not many can resist that dark chocolate fudge swirled with heavenly mint!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Dark Chocolate Fudge. We use dark chocolate to make the creamiest chocolate fudge around. You will love this homemade fudge!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Amaretto Chocolate Swirl is a combination of dark chocolate, cherry and almond. It's irresistibly delicious.
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Chocolate and Peanute Butter Fudge...what better combination is there?! Our fresh fudge is made with dark chocolate and real peanut butter. Simply delicious!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Heath English Toffee Fudge. We combine our fresh vanilla fudge with bits of Heath English Toffee to get creamy fudge with a crunch! You'll love this sweet combo!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Maple Nut Fudge. We use fresh walnuts in our maple nut fudge for a combination that will wow you!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Chocolate Caramel Fudge. We sandwich chewy caramel and peanuts between 2 layers of dark chocolate fudge. Delicious! It'll remind you of one of your favorite candy bars...but better, because it's FUDGE!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Creamsicle Fudge. Dreamy vanilla fudge swirled with orange will bring you back to the days of the ice cream truck, when the best treat was creamsicle ice cream. This fudge will please the kid in you!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Vanilla Walnut Fudge. Sweet, creamy vanilla fudge, and crunchy walnuts...what a combination!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Mocha Fudge. If you love coffee, you will absolutely love this fudge. It's made with real coffee crystals mixed right in for a coffee flavor that can't be beat! You may have heard it called Java Fudge or Coffee Fudge--this homemade fudge is delicious by any name!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Chewy Praline Fudge. This is one of our most popular fudges. One taste and you'll see why...chewy caramel and praline are sandwiched between 2 layers of creamy vanilla fudge. We're sure it will become one of your favorites, too!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Zebra Fudge. What is Zebra fudge you ask? Only the best of all worlds when it comes to fudge. Our Chewy Caramel and Praline center is sandwiched between a layer of Creamy Vanilla Fudge on the bottom and our Dark Chocolate Fudge on top. With Zebra Fudge, you get a little bit of everything!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
Chocolate Walnut Fudge. Creamy, Dark Chocolate Fudge and crunchy, fresh walnuts combine in this popular fudge for a mix that will delight your taste buds!
Please choose 1 lb, 1/2 lb or 1/4 pound. Please note we only ship fudge by the pound, you may choose 4 different flavors in 1/4 pound pieces or 2 different flavors in 1/2 pound pieces. We will package it all together in 1 pound boxes. If you choose the gift wrap option, we will tie a pretty bow around the box.
