All of our fudge is homemade in Papa Dave's kitchen with all natural ingredients like real butter and cream, so you can count on creamy, delicious fudge every time! See our selection of fresh fudges with nuts, dark chocolate, vanilla, chewy caramel and more. Papa Dave makes many unique flavors and more 4,000 pounds of fresh fudge every year. Online ordering is easy. Who is Papa Dave?
Please note: We wait to ship your fudge when the temperature is below 70 degrees.
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
Candy Cane Fudge is a great way to celebrate the holiday season. Vanilla fudge, flavored with peppermint, and topped with crushed candy canes. It's a treat everyone will love! Every...
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
Creamy, vanilla fudge, crunchy walnuts and mini marshmallows combine for a new take on a classic favorite. Love Rocky Road Fudge? You may want to give it's vanilla version a try!...
$ 19.99
Papa Dave's Penuche Praline Fudge sandwiches a layer of chewy caramel and pecans between rich caramel and butterscotch flavors of traditional penuche fudge (which is fudge made with brown sugar instead...
$ 19.99
A creamy and crunchy classic flavor to captivate the taste buds. Papa Dave's Penuche Walnut Fudge combines fresh walnuts with the rich caramel and butterscotch flavors of traditional penuche fudge (which...
$ 19.99
Papa Dave's Amaretto Chocolate Swirl Fudge is a delightfully creamy combination of rich dark chocolate with the sweet, almond flavor of amaretto liqueur (without the alcohol). It's irresistibly delicious! Amaretto is a sweet, liqueur...
$ 19.99
Dark chocolate, real cream and real butter combined in Papa Dave's famous mixer to make the creamiest chocolate fudge around. You will love this homemade fudge! Fudge lovers and chocolate...
$ 19.99
Creamy, dark chocolate fudge and crunchy, fresh walnuts combined in Papa Dave's famous mixer. This classic old-fashioned flavor is our most popular fudge. Made with real cream and real butter, and filled with...
$ 19.99
This is one of our most popular fudges. One taste and you'll see why...chewy caramel and praline are sandwiched between two layers of creamy vanilla fudge. A classic, rich, southern-style delight...
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
Classic dark chocolate fudge layered on top of creamy peanut butter fudge ... what better combination is there?! Our fresh fudge is made with dark chocolate and real peanut butter. Simply...
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
Chocolate Mint Swirl fudge is one of the most popular flavors, a delightful combination of dark chocolate fudge swirled with heavenly mint! Made with real dairy cream and butter. Creamy. Chocolaty....
$ 19.99
We combine our vanilla fudge with bits of Heath English Toffee in Papa Dave's famous mixer to get this creamy fudge with a crunch! You'll love this sweet combo, which takes...
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
Sweet, dreamy vanilla fudge swirled with bright, fragrant orange fudge in Papa Dave's kitchen. This fudge will bring you back to the days of the ice cream truck, when the best...
$ 19.99
Papa Dave's Salted Caramel Fudge is a sinful combination of creamy vanilla fudge delicately blended with gooey ribbons of salted caramel, and topped with coarse sea salt. It's irresistibly delicious! Every pound of fudge will...
$ 19.99
Papa Dave's Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel Fudge is a rich combination of creamy chocolate fudge delicately blended with gooey ribbons of salted caramel, and topped with coarse sea salt. It's irresistibly delicious! Every...
$ 19.99
If you like coffee, you will absolutely love this fudge. We use locally roasted, finely ground espresso to give this fudge its signature flavor. It's like the best mocha topped with...
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
One of the all time classics perfected in Papa's Dave's kitchen (perhaps because it's Papa Dave's favorite flavor). Fresh, crunchy walnuts mixed into maple fudge for a combination to make...
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
Creamy, dark chocolate fudge and crunchy, fresh walnuts and marshmallows combined in Papa Dave's famous mixer. This classic old-fashioned flavor is our most popular fudge. Made with real cream and real butter,...
$ 19.99
This is one of the best mistakes Papa Dave ever made! What started out as an effort to make Chewy Praline (caramel and pecan layered between creamy vanilla fudge) earned its...
$ 19.99
We sandwich chewy caramel and peanuts between two layers of dark chocolate fudge. A salty, savory, crunchy fudge creation. Delicious! It'll remind you of one of your favorite candy bars ... but...
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
Papa Dave's Cookie's and Cream Fudge will make you feel like a kid again. And you don't even need milk for dipping! Every pound of fudge will come tied with...
$ 19.99
Sweet, creamy vanilla fudge combined with crunchy walnuts in Papa Dave's kitchen ... what a combination! One of our favorite fudge's not named "chocolate." Every pound of fudge will come tied...
$ 19.99
A taste of autumn mixed with love in Papa Dave's kitchen. Real pumpkin and pumpkin pie spices combined in a rich, creamy fudge for a flavor sure to remind you...
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
A bold fudge with caramel and butterscotch overtones, perfected in Papa Dave's kitchen. Penuche fudge is made with brown sugar instead of white sugar, and has a distinct color and taste....
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
Papa Dave's Caramel Peanut Fudge may make you think about a favorite candy bar with peanut butter fudge on the bottom, vanilla fudge on top and caramel and peanuts in the...
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
If you close your eyes while you taste Papa Dave's Rootbeer Float Fudge you will swear you're tasting an actual rootbeer float. The creamy vanilla fudge, swirled with rootbeer flavor is...
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
Papa Dave's Peanut Butter Fudge is creamy and peanut buttery! Any peanut butter lover will love this fudge! Every pound of fudge will come tied with a red bow. Our gourmet...
Out of Season/Stock - $ 19.99
Watermelon is one of the best tastes of summer, and we've got it for you directly from Papa Dave's kitchen! Watermelon Fudge is one of our new summertime fudge flavors,...